Referees are a funny breed you might think? Long hours (up to 12 hours a day, often 4 matches in a row), little appreciation, minimal expenses and sometimes a lot of grief.
They are also integral to the match – you can’t play without one; they have an important role to play and therefore, they can have a direct impact on your emotions, performance and your result.
How then should we interact with them to help us achieve our goal, or indeed should we be seeking to gain an advantage by our attitude towards them? Let’s look at it from the officials’ view point first.
How would referees like and expect to be treated? With respect one would assume. Not only is this just decent, polite and friendly behaviour, but also it means that you won’t have put his/her nose out of joint before you’ve even appealed for a decision.
“It’s not just what the player says, but the manner and tone of voice which is so important, and from referees too of course.” Explains John Massarella. So it follows you can then expect to get the same level of respect from the official.
“We’d like the player to speak with respect, and a referee should reciprocate when answering the players and in giving an explanation of the decision when asked. It is then up to the referee to decide if the player is continually querying decisions, whether it is a genuine query, or part of some other tactic.”
So from this we learn that we need to be selective with our communication. James Willstrop agrees. “It is valid to make a point to the referee I think, if you feel something is going on which the referee hasn’t noticed or isn’t understanding, but it should be done without shouting and threatening, if at all possible! I would say though, in my personal view, keep it to a minimum. It is only a distraction.”
It seems that the consensus then is that making a point to the referee is fine from the referee's point of view but as James points out, it’s better if sparingly. If you are consistently being blocked out, pushed or falling to some other form of dubious activity, explaining to the referee may help your case the next time it happens. The trick is not to look like, or indeed be a moaner, so be calm, concise and don’t make a habit of it.
I ask James whether he has any advice on how to treat the referee in order to keep them (the officials) onside.
“I don't think keeping refs 'onside' is the way to go. Referees shouldn't swing in favour of anyone anyway, and if they do they are probably just as likely to go with the badly behaved player. I don't treat the referee with respect because I am trying to grease up to him. I am behaving in that way because I feel it is the most productive way of playing, and why shouldn't referees have your respect anyway?” An admirable stance. Also, clearly one which has worked well for him and helped him gain a reputation as one of, if not the most, fair players on the PSA tour.
If you win a rally, there is no need to point out to the ref that he’s missed the out ball earlier as this has no positive impact on your goal (to win the match) and in fact will only antagonise the ref and make the likelihood of any 50/50 decisions going your way in future, that bit smaller. Perhaps a more questioning approach would be a better strategy – i.e. to find out what the referee would like you as the player, to do, and allow him to direct you as John would suggest.So we have complete agreement on treating the referee with respect from player and referee as one might expect. What then, are the latest edicts coming from the referees in relation to the way the game is officiated? If we can understand the rules a little better, then this can only help our, the player’s, situation. “We need to toughen up on no lets and strokes. Refereeing needs to be firmed up with more strokes for not clearing and less lets where there is minimal interference or lack of effort.” John states. So you heard it here first. Get out of the way and play the ball wherever possible, or face the consequences.
From a coach’s perspective, here are a few tips when asking for lets.